Cold Weather Running – Rebook and Under Armour Review


October 21, 2012 by IowaTriBob

Not wanting to give in to the cold weather just yet I decided to go shopping for some cold weather running gear. Unfortunately I had the perfect day to try my purchases out this past week as the weather in Iowa was low 40’s with a very cold rain and I was determined to run outside.

Now I’ve never been much of a cold weather person when it comes to working out and would prefer an upper 80’s to low 90’s day with mild humidity. In fact, sometimes the hotter the better as I enjoy being able to stay loose, warm, and with a good sweat going. This also means for the most part I’ve never really tried to work out during the colder Iowa months so this was definitely a new adventure for me.

From reading and viewing what others were wearing I made my list to look for:

• Base layer leggings and top
• Outer shell top for rainy and windy days just like today
• Outer shell bottom for really cold days
• Head protection
• Wool socks
• Gloves

For my head protection I purchased a Nike Therma-Fit beanie (which I absolutely loved during my first cold run), for my outer shell top I purchased a Koppen Men’s Rain Jacket, and for my base layer top I purchased a Reebok men’s cold weather thermal compression mock neck shirt. I decided to skip the wool socks, gloves, and bottom shell at this time as I figured I’d save those for the really cold days ahead. Besides, I figured I might be able to find something equivalent at home already.

For my base layer leggings I was undecided between a pair of Reebok men’s cold weather compression tights and Under Armour men’s Evo ColdGear compression tights, both were priced the exact same at $50 so decided to give both a try and see which ones I liked better.

Reebok Cold Weather Compression Elevate Tightsrebook_compression_tights


• Compression fit for a snug feel and muscle support
• Plush elastic jacquard waistband is soft and works to keep the tights in place
• Gusseted fit provides a superb range of motion and the best fit
• Play Dry Technology wicks away moisture to keep you dry
• Fabric: 87% polyester, 13% spandex

Under Armour Evo ColdGear CompressionUnder Armour_coldgear_compression


• Signature Under Armour® compression fit for top performance
• Updated brushback knit fabrication traps heat for enhanced warmth
• Strategically placed windowpane mesh to ensure dryness and comfort
• Performance waistband
• Specialized fully functional ventilated fly
• Fabric: 7.1 oz. 87% polyester, 13% elastane.

When I got home I decided to give the Rebook’s a try first. Now I’ve never worn full legging tights before so there was definitely some getting used to. After I managed to get them on (which was much harder than one would think) I was extremely surprised at how comfortable and warm they felt. The compression in them wasn’t restricting and the fit around my legs and waist felt just right. The seams in the tights were positioned in the right areas along my legs so that once correctly aligned I never noticed them again.

This was my long run day and I never even thought about the Rebook tights again after putting them on, which in my opinion was a very good thing. My legs stayed warm and I didn’t feel or notice the light steady rain or wind on them.

Next I decided to try the Under Armour Evo CG Compression tights. The experience with putting them on and how they initially felt was almost identical to the Reebok tights; however this was as far as the similarities went.

During the second half of my run with the UA’s I noticed several differences. The seams in the UA tights were positioned in a fashion that I could feel them around my thighs and knees. Regardless of how I tried to shift them they would fall back into a position where they were noticeable. The seams didn’t look any different than the Reeboks but there must have been a few centimeter difference on the position as I could feel a little rub which made me paranoid about chaffing.

The second noticeable difference was the front fly section. The Rebook’s had a consistent feeling all throughout the mid-section and groin area while the UA’s “specialized fully functional ventilated fly” seemed to keep almost a saggy pocket (again it made me paranoid about chaffing). The last and probably most important difference was the warmth. For whatever reason the UA’s almost felt a little drafty at times and it seemed like when the wind blew at just the right angle I could feel a little chill in my legs.

Not wanting to discount the UA’s just yet I tried them on a short run and bike ride the next day and noticed the exact same issues as the day before.

For running I’ll definitely be using the Rebook compression tights on a regular basis and keep the UA’s as a backup or for a base layer / long john replacement during cold outdoor wear outside of my workouts.

With my new cold weather gear I hate to say I’m almost looking forward to my winter runs in the coming months.

8 thoughts on “Cold Weather Running – Rebook and Under Armour Review

  1. elisariva says:

    One of my most favorite runs was in January, sunshine and 13 degrees. Proper clothes and gear makes all the difference!

  2. Carrie says:

    Interesting observations. I’ve been using Under Armour bottoms and tops since high school, and I absolutely love the brand. Last week, I did buy a pair of Lululemon running tights, but I haven’t tried them out yet because it hasn’t been cold enough. (I definitely couldn’t say the same if I were still living in Syracuse–I think they’ve had some snow already!) Having the right gears makes all the difference.

    • IowaTriBob says:

      I’ve heard great things about them as well and the UA brand has definitely continued to grow over the years. For some reason though the Rebook’s just felt better and I even tried the UA’s twice thinking maybe it was something I did the first time around. I guess that’s why choices are a good thing for us.

  3. Chatter says:

    It might also be a matter of body size and build. I am a big guy with tree trunks for legs and usually the under armor fits better. Of course they are also one of the few who make 3x size in this stuff!!! BTW don’t even bother with Walmarts driwick compression shorts, while cheaper they are paper thin.

  4. Yasser says:

    Help :)
    I am moving to Canada from Florida (!!!). My questions are:
    1- Will the reebock legging be enough for temp. in the teens?
    2- Do I need to put normal pants on top in order not to look weird ?? :)
    3- I am a big guy with BIG legs. Will the reebock one be too tight?


    • IowaTriBob says:

      First of all, thank you for commenting and sorry to hear about the move :-). Most people I know are trying to go the opposite direction. Based on my experience running in the Iowa winter this year with temps down into the single digits:

      1. If the temps are in the teens (or anything below 30 degrees for me – I like to run warm) you’ll want to add a windproof and waterproof outer shell to add some additional layering.

      2. That is really a preference. I tend to always throw a pair of shorts over mine just to make me feel a little less self conscious, however I see plenty of people with just the compression tights out and about.

      3. Having run consistently now in both the Reebok and UA over the past several months I think you might actually find a little more comfort in the UA tights. I have bigger thighs and always prefer the relax fit jeans over the regular or slim but also wouldn’t consider my legs to be big. I tend to favor the Reebok’s more, but if my legs were any bigger in the thigh and calves the Reebok’s might feel a little to tight, where the UA’s tend to feel a little more roomy. Of course both would assume you size them right to start with.

      Hope these help and good luck with the move north…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Single-tracked Mind

Early nights and compression tights; trails and ales.

First Time Triathlete

All the info you need to get to the start line, the rest is up to you.

The Running Thriver

If I can do it, so can you!


A ridiculous man's struggle to become an Iron Man in 12 months

Stewart Park Triathlon

Competitive Triathlon - My Journey


My take on cycling!


sus·ing (soo’zing) n. an occurrence of life filtered through Susie’s perspective, spiced with a dash of wit and self-deprecation, and presented for entertainment's sake

Forty and Loving Fit

Husband, Father, and IT Pro training for triathlons on a 5 hour weekly budget.

Fitness and Frozen Grapes

Sweating, eating, and living my life as a young college graduate

Flatlander Tri Coaching

The home of anything and everything related to triathlon

Consulting Expert in Fitness, Health, Krav Maga, Personal Training and Nutrition

My journey to become an Ironman

Most people run a race to see who is fastest. I run a race to see who has the most guts.

10k Ray

Blog about Running & Triathlon in Ireland

Mom Racing Madness

When motherhood, a full-time career, and endurance athletics collide!


Old triathletes never die, they just transition....

The Shut Down Runner

Adventures in running...faster

Fat Guy to Tri Guy

My journey from being grossly over weight to completing an IRONMAN

heidi jo green

At the End of the Day it is Entirely up to You Who You Want to BE...

Triability Coaching

Professional Coaching for Endurance Athletes


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 147 other followers

%d bloggers like this: